Receiving-site gap assessmentQuality agreement reviewFirst-lot release records
Home / CDMO transfer milestones and acceptance criteria

CDMO transfer milestones and acceptance criteria

Distinguish file delivery, quality approval and commercial milestone acceptance when comparing transfer proposals.

Describe an observable end point for each stage

A quotation might describe a payment point simply as dossier delivery. Ask which named files, approved revisions and document index constitute that delivery, who can receive it and whether a separate review period follows. WHO’s technology transfer framework provides context for the stages and responsibilities of pharmaceutical transfers. The commercial payment trigger remains a contractual decision for the organisations involved. Record the proposed terms alongside the technical scope before comparing bids.

WHO (2022) · Technology transfer in pharmaceutical manufacturing, TRS 1044 Annex 4

Rows of cartons are stacked on pallets in the UNICEF warehouse in Copenhagen.
Palletised shipping cartonsPallets, outer cases and inner units are different levels to record when reconciling a shipment.
Image creditsheb (Wikimedia Commons) · Image source · CC BY-SA 3.0 · Converted to WebP.
Two operators in blue protective clothing guide a sheet over a metal work surface.
Sheet handling at the worktableThe sheet and work surface provide context for recording the handling stage associated with an inspected unit.
Image creditsCompany footage

Identify who can acknowledge each type of decision

A document coordinator may acknowledge receipt, a quality representative may accept specified quality evidence and a purchasing manager may approve a commercial invoice. Give each decision its own owner and evidence requirement. The FDA guidance on quality agreements discusses the allocation of quality responsibilities in contract drug manufacturing. Where that framework is relevant, preserve the agreed independence of quality decisions when drafting commercial milestone language.

FDA (2016) · Quality agreements in contract drug manufacturing

Compare two offers against the same acceptance record

Imagine Bid A invoices when the indexed files reach the buyer, while Bid B invoices after the receiving site accepts the reviewed set. Both may use the same milestone name. Ask each bidder to describe the review window, how missing items are reported, who decides if a submission is complete and what happens if comments are raised. A one-page acceptance record with an explicit status lets the buyer compare timing and follow-up work on equal terms.

Prepare your inquiry

Make delivery, technical approval and invoicing separately traceable in a transfer proposal.

Select the items you want to ask about.

Certificates of analysis

For a transferred lyophilized powder project, compare the issuing site, lot identifier and certificate version with the agreed first-lot release record.

Read a COA